TONY'S TOWN SQUARE RESTAURANT

TONY'S TOWN SQUARE RESTAURANT grades better than most of its neighbors: safer than 87% of Orange County restaurants we grade, holding an A at 99/100.

Its latest inspection on June 24, 2026 cited 1 basic violation. Diners give it 4.2 across 3,218 reviews. It's a Italian spot in Bay Lake. Menus here flag options for vegan, vegetarian, and organic diners.

A · 99/100 · safer than 87% of Orange County restaurants we grade

Get directions Call (407) 939-5277

Restaurant details

Health grade
A (99/100)
Violations
1 total — 1 basic
Address
1365 N MONORAIL WAY, Bay Lake, FL
Cuisine
Italian
Categories
Italian restaurant, Bar, Restaurant
Price
$20–30
Rating
4.2 stars (3218 reviews)
Seats
300
Phone
(407) 939-5277
Website
Official website
Photo of TONY'S TOWN SQUARE RESTAURANT
Photo: Tony's Town Square Restaurant

Community Rating

Reviews via Google
4.2 Community-sourced rating 3,218 reviews
Read all reviews on Google →

What diners say — our read

The recurring subject in this corpus is front-of-house, not the food in general. Where the staff comes up, the rating that follows averages 4.5, so it reads as a strength.

More reviewers landed on 5 stars than any other score — 15 of 26. The split is 20 positive to 3 negative across 26 rated reviews, with 3 in the middle. Whether it is worth the money shows up in 15% of reviews as well, averaging 3.0.

On the inspection side the picture is cleaner: DBPR graded this kitchen an A (99/100), with 1 basic violations. Whatever the reviews argue about, sanitation is not the weak point. That result dates from June 24, 2026. Ranked against Orange County, it is safer than 87% of the restaurants we score. What the inspector actually wrote up: wiping cloths.

With both signals pointing the same way, there is little to argue about on this listing. The underlying reviews are reproduced in full underneath.

Our own analysis of 26 reviews for this restaurant, set against its Florida DBPR inspection record. How we calculate grades →

  • June 29, 2026

    The cheese sticks and bread are must haves!

  • June 25, 2026

    I absolutely love Toney’s! The decor is very on point and the overall food is outstanding! Service was phenomenal with our host, Jim, who brought the experience to life! I absolutely recommend Tony’s to all kids and adults!

  • June 24, 2026

    Food was fantastic. And our server was amazing

  • June 23, 2026

    Tony's is authentic Italian American fare. The garlic bread and insalata caprese were wonderful to start with. The chicken parm was some of the best I ever had. Will be returning soon!

  • June 21, 2026

    This place was amazing this waiter was from Italy and treated us very well I’ve been all over the United States and this guy was the best thanks Vincenzo from Italy you truly blessed us god bless!

  • June 20, 2026

    Garlic bread was fantastic. Chicken parm was extremely bland. I think it was definitely overpriced.

  • June 20, 2026

    The garlic bread and mozzarella sticks are a must. The pastas are ok. They're a little expensive but all in all...good place to eat for a theme park. Get the appetizers and share the pastas!

  • June 15, 2026

    Ceasar salad was dressed greatly and yummy. Chicken Alfredo was a hit and miss. The sauce was yummy but they used boiled chicken (which wasn't good)._

  • June 14, 2026

    I used to love going here because of all of their gluten free options but I went today and was told they now have a limited gluten free menu. So sad!

  • June 10, 2026

    Tony’s Town Square is easily one of the worst dining experiences I’ve had at Disney, and I have been to many Disney restaurants! The disaster starts with the check-in process. It’s completely disorganized, with no meaningful seating in the lobby for waiting guests. Instead, you’re left standing around in a crowded area while staff mumble names that are nearly impossible to hear or understand. For a restaurant that serves this many people every day, it’s astonishing how poorly managed the front end is. The bathrooms are another example of poor planning. They are far too small for the volume of guests, creating unnecessary lines and frustration. Who knows the last time they were properly cleaned! Once you’re finally seated, be prepared to wait. And wait. And wait. The food takes an unreasonable amount of time to arrive, only for it to be incredibly underwhelming. The menu is bland, uninspired, and tastes more like cafeteria food than a restaurant charging Disney prices. The most frustrating part is the cost. Tony’s charges premium Disney prices for a bargain-basement dining experience. You’re paying a fortune for mediocre food, slow service, and a chaotic atmosphere. Disney is known for creating exceptional guest experiences, but Tony’s Town Square feels like a place that survives solely because of its location on Main Street, not because it earns repeat customers. There are countless better places to spend your money in Magic Kingdom. Save your time, save your money, and eat…

  • June 10, 2026

    The large restaurant is located in Bay Lake, Florida in Magic Kingdom. It is part of Disney World and near Orlando. They prepare Italian cuisine. Reservations are recommended. The restaurant is inspired from the classic Disney movie Lady and the Tramp. Soups 🍲, salads 🥗, appetizers, desserts 🍨 and beverages ☕️ are on the menu. My friends and family celebrated a birthday during our dinner. The food was very good and well-prepared. Friendly and helpful staff.

  • June 8, 2026

    Highly recommend getting the Rigatoni alla Vodka and adding sausage!

  • June 8, 2026

    Brilliant service, particularly from Gardo, Diego and Alex. Highly recommend

  • June 5, 2026

    Great location.great food and service

  • June 2, 2026

    So glad we made reservations for this place. The food is absolutely delicious! My wife and daughter will be talking about the shrimp scampi for years to come. I’m not a huge fan of shrimp, so I personally went with the classic spaghetti and meatballs (in honor of Lady and the Tramp). The meatballs were the star of the dish. Is certainly order it again. Mrs. Jackie was a great waitress (she’s been at Tony’s for 17 years), and the atmosphere is great for an Italian restaurant. We’ll be back here again on our next visit to Magic Kingdom. NOTE: Our food didn’t last long enough to make it in the picture. It was that good 😁

  • June 2, 2026

    This was our first time back to Tony’s Town Square in years and we were not disappointed. Out aside any past experiences and give it a try. The service was excellent. The garlic bread was so good I would go back just for this. The kids said their Mac and Cheese was delicious also. The restaurant brings you right into the movie of Lady and the Tramp and is very elegant which could be great for an adult date night. We definitely will be back and recommending to our clients.

  • May 31, 2026

    Lo recomiendo , es de lo mejores restaurantes italiano que he visitado

  • May 24, 2026

    Italian food? Italian food? This is an insult to every Italian , domestic or foreign. The food was atrocious. DO NOT EAT HERE if you are one scintilla italian or know an italian.

  • May 20, 2026

    First time at Tony's on May 19 2026 and loved everything. Our waiter Miguel was fantastic. The smell of the food when walk in was excellent. Miguel should be given a lot of praise. How i ask about everything he made sure I got it. My only draw back wasn't seated in the main room.they explained to us when making reservations request inside. We will be back. I had a perfect day in magic kingdom and perfect dinner. Can't wait to go back. Miguel you are wonderful.

  • May 19, 2026

    A comida estava ótima, bem preparada e saborosa. No entanto, a experiência como um todo foi prejudicada por alguns pontos importantes. Fomos colocados em uma área da varanda onde batia muito sol, o que tornou a refeição desconfortável. Além disso, o banheiro não estava limpo no momento da nossa visita. O ponto mais desagradável aconteceu na hora da sobremesa. Minha esposa, por causa do sol e do desconforto, mudou temporariamente para outra mesa próxima, em uma área praticamente vazia. Havia apenas a nossa mesa e mais uma família na varanda. Mesmo assim, o gerente veio até ela e, de forma bastante grosseira, disse que aquela mesa era para outros clientes. Ela voltou para a nossa mesa, terminou de comer, e a mesa da qual foi retirada permaneceu vazia. Entendemos que restaurantes precisam organizar suas mesas, mas faltou bom senso e cordialidade no atendimento. A comida merece elogios, mas o serviço e a condução da situação deixaram muito a desejar.

  • May 19, 2026

    Demora demais! Sabor deixa a desejar, pouca quantidade e extremamente caro

  • May 18, 2026

    I absolutely love Tony’s on Main Street right inside the entrance to Magic Kingdom. We reserve a table for a late dinner around 8pm so we can watch the parade from our table. Garlic bread is the best anywhere and the fried mozzarella is my favorite. Typical Italian dishes, desserts, and outstanding service.

  • May 15, 2026

    Been going to Disney for decades. The new Tony’s is great. Salmon was perfect and rigatoni marinara was the best. A must try if you went to the old Tony’s and didn’t like it. Totally different experience now.

  • May 13, 2026

    The food was decent, and as expected for Disney World, definitely on the overpriced side. The service was great, though. We enjoyed a wonderful glass of wine and loved the atmosphere. We’ll still choose to eat here again during one of our many visits to the Magic Kingdom.

  • May 13, 2026

    It is good and could be great. I liked it. The restaurant is beautiful and we had a good experience. Our waiter was very nice, but we didn’t see very much of him. It is also extremely loud! I imagine it’s because of where we sat and if we sat outside it wouldn’t have been as bad but it was very hard to hear each other. The menu is small. The food is good especially the garlic bread and mozzarella sticks. The spaghetti is amazing. The Alfredo is good but very rich. My daughter and I couldn’t finish it. The shrimp scampi wasn’t bad but I couldn’t tell if the shrimp was fresh or frozen. I think we will go back for the bread and maybe try some different pasta next time. Over all it’s a nice restaurant.

  • May 11, 2026

    I am so happy we ate here. We were nervous to come and spend a bunch of money at a place with bad reviews! Tony’s was great! Our server Lindsay S was great! The garlic bread, scampi, and fettuccini Alfredo were quite delicious! Listen it’s not food straight from Italy but it is a great Disney food spot! We will be back several more times!!!

Overall Score

72 / 100

  • Health inspection grade 40/40
    Grade A
  • Dietary transparency 10/20
    3 options listed
  • Community rating 17/20
    4.2★ average
  • Hidden-gem status 0/10
    Not flagged
  • Track record 5/10
    Stable, 33% clean

Composite score from health grade, dietary options, ratings, and inspection record — distinct from the state-derived health grade.

Opening hours

Monday
11 AM to 2:55 PM, 3 to 9 PM
Tuesday
11 AM to 2:55 PM, 3 to 9 PM
Wednesday
11 AM to 2:55 PM, 3 to 9 PM
Thursday
11 AM to 2:55 PM, 3 to 9 PM
Friday
11 AM to 2:55 PM, 3 to 9 PM
Saturday
11 AM to 2:55 PM, 3 to 9 PM
Sunday
11 AM to 2:55 PM, 3 to 9 PM

Inspection history

The following records are from Florida DBPR public inspection records, most recent first.

  1. June 24, 2026 · Complaint Full

    Inspection Completed - No Further Action

    0 high-priority · 0 intermediate · 1 basic

    • 21 — Wiping cloths; clean & soiled linens; laundry
  2. April 21, 2026 · Routine - Food

    Inspection Completed - No Further Action

    0 high-priority · 0 intermediate · 0 basic

    No violations cited.

  3. October 22, 2025 · Routine - Food

    Inspection Completed - No Further Action

    0 high-priority · 2 intermediate · 3 basic

    • 03 — Temperature control of foods (cold/hot holding, cooking, cooling, reheating)
    • 08 — Cross-contamination: raw foods separated; food protected during prep/storage
    • 13 — Clean clothes; hair restraints; jewelry; fingernails
    • 22 — Food-contact surfaces clean and sanitized
    • 25 — Single-service and single-use items

This grade is calculated by us from Florida DBPR public inspection records — Florida does not issue official grades. How we calculate it →

Data last updated: June 24, 2026