OUR EL MARIES PIZZERIA & SUB SHOPPE
Does OUR EL MARIES PIZZERIA & SUB SHOPPE keep a clean kitchen? Yes — an A grade, 90/100, at its most recent inspection on December 1, 2025. That visit logged 1 high-priority and 2 basic violations.
On health score it's safer than 61% of Lake County restaurants we grade. Diners rate it 4.7 from 1,003 reviews. Cuisine: Pizza. Menus here flag options for vegetarian diners.
Get directions Call (352) 483-9111
Restaurant details
- Health grade
- A (90/100)
- Violations
- 3 total — 1 high-priority, 2 basic
- Address
- 200 N BAY ST, Eustis, FL
- Cuisine
- Pizza
- Categories
- Pizza restaurant
- Price
- $10–20
- Rating
- 4.7 stars (1003 reviews)
- Seats
- 36
- Phone
- (352) 483-9111
- Website
- Official website
Community Rating
Reviews via GoogleWhat diners say — our read
Little tension on this listing: diners rate it well and the kitchen graded well. Reviewers who mention how guests are treated rate this place 4.8 on average — it is working in the restaurant’s favour. How much food arrives follows at 25% of reviews, where ratings average 4.8.
5 stars is the modal score, given by 21 of the 24 reviewers who rated. Of the 24 rated reviews, 24 sit at four stars or better and 0 at two or below.
On the inspection side the picture is cleaner: DBPR graded this kitchen an A (90/100), with 1 high-priority and 2 basic violations. Whatever the reviews argue about, sanitation is not the weak point. That inspection was on December 1, 2025. That puts it ahead of 61% of graded kitchens in Lake County. Among the items recorded were nonfood-contact surfaces clean and single-service and single-use items.
Both measures agree, which is the least complicated version of this page. Read the originals below and judge the pattern yourself.
Our own analysis of 24 reviews for this restaurant, set against its Florida DBPR inspection record. How we calculate grades →
-
Went there for Father's Day dinner. It was an overall great experience. We enjoyed the garlic knots, large white pizza, small tuna sub and small pops Italian sub. The staff was friendly and the music was great. Highly recommend.
-
We live about 20 miles from El Marie, but always go there before attending a play at The State Theatre. Yesterday afternoon when we arrived we were shocked and sorry to learn of the owner's fatal motorcycle accident last September. Our thoughts and prayers to his family and the El Marie staff. Yesterday we simply shared a "small" Italian sub. It isn't small, but we already knew that...as always it was delicious. In the past we have had their salads and their pizzas -- everything there is very good. We were glad to see they were quite busy on a Sunday afternoon, and the service was excellent and friendly. Like a dummy, I left my sunglasses on the table, stopped back 3 hours later, after the show, and the staff returned them to me, as good as new! Thanks for a great meal -- and I do hope the public continues to support this fine local business!
-
Great canzone
-
Great service. Food was amazing from salad to calzone.
-
Just moved near by recently and have tried 4 Pizza places and was about to give up when we said one more. Thank goodness we did. Excellent Pizza. The crust is crispy, the sauce is not sweet and more marinara/tomato.
-
Did not dine in It was my first time getting food from there. Ordered a large meat lovers. Pizza had a very good amount of ingredients Was a very good tasting pizza. Ordered from there. Because of location for a place to stop on my way home from work. We'll be trying other things from from here in the future Would recommend this place to everyone
-
Delicious, Delicious, delicious best pizza i had so far in florida. The sandwiches look enormous but I've never had one myself yet. Will update when I do
-
Their cauliflower pizza crust was so good!
-
This is the best pizza in the area. You will be missing a rare delicacy if you don't make a stop at El Marie pizzeria by the lake in Eustis Florida....yeah
-
Man, talk about a SANDWICH! I had the El Marie Roast Beef. The large is enough for two. Ciabatta roll was delightful, fresh ingredients, definitely enjoyed. About the same price as subway but not even close to the same league. Saw a few customers having pizza and they looked amazing. I will go back when in the area
-
There's nothing better than El Maries for Pizza and sandwiches! Awesome service and the cleanest restaurant around ! Its hands down our favorite spot❣️❣️
-
Ambiente, comida y servicio DE DIEZ ESTRELLAS. La ubicación es perfecta porque después de comer pizza puedes ir a resposar caminando por el parque o el muelle. Las pizzas son RIQUÍSIMAS. La de queso normal es deliciosa, así que no tienes que irte por algo más. Lo clásico es rico igual. De todos modos, yo me comí la que tiene queso ricotta con la mitad de todas las carnes Y LA DISFRUTÉ MUCHÍSIMO. Ws una delicia. Exquisita. El trato es de la misma calidad que del sabor. Aprecié muchísimo a la muchacha por su servicio tan completo y paciente. Volveré sin duda.
-
Located on the corner of Ferran park, this pizza joint provides a pie to rival the view. The ingredients are high quality and the flavors all shine.
-
Food was amazing! Very fresh high quality ingredients. We will definitely be back
-
Everything, no disappointments
-
First time trying, Addison was our server and we were taken care of wonderful. First Antipasta salad the small was plenty for 2 and was very good and had with the garlic knots and came with marinara sauce amazing . Pizza was so authentic crust delicious. Will definitely be back. Great location and very clean. Good parking.
-
Friendly
-
Best Garlic Knots I’ve EVER had! The meat lovers pizza was delicious as well. Fast/ friendly service and clean establishment
-
Great service but mixed quality food. My calzone was decent but the pizza was below average. Subs served at other tables looked good and were very large. No draft beer. Enjoyed our visit on a quiet afternoon.
-
So good. Glad we chose this place for dinner. If we were locals we would definitely be back.
-
Great floppy pizza. Great Subs. Best garlic knots I've found. Lots of garlic and Fluffy bread.
-
Outstanding Sub & Salad
-
We have not been disappointed any time we have been to El Marie. The food is delicious! We have ordered pizza, stromboli, greek salad and the best garlic knots loaded with garlic. The only disappointment is their tea needs to be stronger so that it tastes like tea. So be warned before ordering.
-
Stopped by today.Excellent food. Place is spotless, even restrooms. Nice people. Can't wait to go back ! See ya Real Soon ! Oh wait, did I say we like this place? Well we did .
Overall Score
66 / 100
Composite score from health grade, dietary options, ratings, and inspection record — distinct from the state-derived health grade.
Opening hours
- Monday
- 11 AM to 8 PM
- Tuesday
- 11 AM to 8 PM
- Wednesday
- 11 AM to 8 PM
- Thursday
- 11 AM to 8 PM
- Friday
- 11 AM to 9 PM
- Saturday
- 11 AM to 9 PM
- Sunday
- 11 AM to 7 PM
Inspection history
The following records are from Florida DBPR public inspection records, most recent first.
-
December 1, 2025 · Routine - Food
Inspection Completed - No Further Action
1 high-priority · 0 intermediate · 2 basic
- 03 — Temperature control of foods (cold/hot holding, cooking, cooling, reheating)
- 23 — Nonfood-contact surfaces clean
- 25 — Single-service and single-use items
This grade is calculated by us from Florida DBPR public inspection records — Florida does not issue official grades. How we calculate it →
Data last updated: December 1, 2025