TIBBY'S NEW ORLEANS KITCHEN

The letter looks fine; the direction doesn't. TIBBY'S NEW ORLEANS KITCHEN holds a C (71/100), but its inspections have been getting worse, not better.

Its most recent inspection on April 17, 2026 cited 2 high-priority, 2 intermediate, and 7 basic violations. It currently ranks safer than 10% of Seminole County restaurants we grade. Diner rating: 4.6 from 4,776 reviews.

Trend: declining · C (71/100)

Get directions Call (407) 951-6928

Restaurant details

Health grade
C (71/100)
Violations
11 total — 2 high-priority, 2 intermediate, 7 basic
Address
494 W SR 436 STE 1016, Altamonte Springs, FL
Cuisine
Other
Categories
Cajun restaurant, Brunch restaurant, Caterer, Cocktail bar, Event venue, Southern restaurant (US)
Price
$20–30
Rating
4.6 stars (4776 reviews)
Seats
162
Phone
(407) 951-6928
Website
Official website
Photo of TIBBY'S NEW ORLEANS KITCHEN
Photo: Tibby's New Orleans Kitchen

Community Rating

Reviews via Google
4.6 Community-sourced rating 4,776 reviews
Read all reviews on Google →

What diners say — our read

One subject runs through these 21 reviews more than any other: front-of-house. Where the staff comes up, the rating that follows averages 4.8, so it reads as a strength.

More reviewers landed on 5 stars than any other score — 17 of 21. The split is 20 positive to 1 negative across 21 rated reviews.

The kitchen graded a C (71/100) on 2 high-priority, 2 intermediate, and 7 basic violations at its last inspection, which is roughly where the reviews sit too. That result dates from April 17, 2026. The trend across inspections is decline. Ranked against Seminole County, it is safer than 10% of the restaurants we score. What the inspector actually wrote up: potentially hazardous foods properly thawed and cross-contamination.

Neither signal is decisive on its own here, which is why both are shown. Full reviews follow below in the order they were left.

Our own analysis of 21 reviews for this restaurant, set against its Florida DBPR inspection record. How we calculate grades →

  • June 30, 2026

    The binets with praline sauce was fantastic. Ordered pork chops with red beans & rice. The portion was large enough to satisfy 2 adults. The sweet potato fries had cinnamon sugar sprinkled on top. So good.

  • June 27, 2026

    This was my fourth time eating at your restaurant, and I continue to be impressed. Not only has the food been incredible during every visit, but the service has been consistently exceptional as well. I have had different servers each time, and every person I have come into contact with—from the young man at the front door to the servers and management—has been incredibly kind and attentive. Tonight, I especially enjoyed having Jasmine as our server. She was the sweetest young lady and so attentive; I truly loved the experience. Thank you for maintaining such a high standard of service.

  • June 26, 2026

    We had a tremendous experience today. The service was amazing. Sierra was one of the best servers we ever had, the apps came out fast and the food was really fresh. We will definitely be back

  • June 26, 2026

    I recently celebrated my 48th birthday at Tibby’s, and I cannot say enough wonderful things about my experience! From the moment we arrived, the atmosphere was warm, vibrant, and full of positive energy. The restaurant has such a fun and inviting New Orleans vibe that made my celebration feel extra special. The food was absolutely amazing—every dish was flavorful, fresh, and beautifully prepared. Our entire party thoroughly enjoyed their meals, and there was truly something for everyone to enjoy. What really stood out was the exceptional service. The staff was attentive, friendly, and accommodating throughout the entire evening. They made sure that my guests and I were well taken care of, which allowed me to relax and fully enjoy celebrating with family and friends. Tibby’s helped make my 48th birthday a memorable and wonderful celebration. I am so grateful to the entire team for helping create such a special experience. If you’re looking for great food, excellent service, and an amazing atmosphere, I highly recommend Tibby’s! Thank you, Tibby’s, for making my birthday celebration one to remember! 🎉💜🎭

  • June 26, 2026

    Perfect as always

  • June 25, 2026

    We reserved the Napoleon Room for our team outing and it was a big hit! Great service, excellent food and a beautiful atmosphere. We will be going back!

  • June 24, 2026

    We enjoy Tibby's and go often. Even on busy occasions, we always come away fat and happy

  • June 23, 2026

    The place is fascinating clean friendly staff great waitress. Have the Hemingway drink fantastic

  • June 21, 2026

    Just had Father's Day dinner at Tibbys. Super fast service on a crazy busy night. Our server was Toni and she was amazing! I highly recommend stopping if you haven't already!

  • June 20, 2026

    This place had some of the best food I’ve had and almost a decade. I honestly feel like I could’ve been on New Orleans right on Bourbon Street.

  • June 20, 2026

    Great place to enjoy Cajun food. Friendly staff and great food.

  • June 20, 2026

    There's nothing wrong with the food, and I love the creativity, I actually have a whole star just for the menu content, but for the prices I felt like the food was just ok. The service is 5-star though and the vibe is just amazing. I will be back.

  • June 19, 2026

    I ordered the Jambalaya, Crawfish Pie, Chicken Gumbo lunch combo. The Gumbo was good, however, the Jambalaya was almost cold and had practically no sausage, and the crawfish pie was barely warm. Overall the entire cost was $27.93 for takeout. No drinks. I won't be going there again. Looked nice inside though.

  • June 17, 2026

    Similar was the absolute best! He was very sweet, catering, knowledgeable and funny. I would come back just to have him as a waiter, the phenomenal food is a bonus!!

  • June 16, 2026

    I hosted my graduate school graduation celebration at Tibbys, and it was a wonderful experience! Erica, was so kind and incredibly accommodating and made the process of reserving the private room seamless and stress-free. Thank you Erica! The entire staff was kind and welcoming, and our server, Shay, was patient, attentive, and provided excellent service. Everyone made me feel so special on such an important day. They even gave me a card, which was such sweet gesture! I’m grateful for the experience and will definitely be back for future celebrations….and to try their brunch! 😋 Thanks Tibby’s!

  • June 15, 2026

    Waitress disappeared most of the meal. No salt, pepper, or extra napkins without asking. Then she'd forget. We never did get salt or extra napkins...only pepper.

  • June 14, 2026

    Out waitresses (Riley) was very attentive and gave some great recommendations on the menu. The food came out very quickly and tasted amazing. There is also alot of cool pieces of art to look at while you eat!

  • June 12, 2026

    Tibby's was incredible. In town for work and this place was recommended by a local legend named Rudd. The server was great and so friendly. Walked my friend and I through the menu and gave great recommendations. Every bite was great but my personal favorite was the debris spring rolls (10/10) and the shrimp and grit cakes: Monica style. Will definitely be back.

  • June 8, 2026

    The food is always excellent and authentic. Service at times can be a little slow but the atmosphere and music make up for it.

  • June 7, 2026

    This place, in my opinion, is an awesome brunch place as well as an everyday place to get some delicious New Orleans food, drinks and atmosphere! I had the sausage and biscuits & my husband had the country fried pork chops, so yummy! Tibby's is full of memorabilia from NO! Don't say no, go to Tibby's, today!!!!

  • June 7, 2026

    There were 14 of us celebrating a birthday. We had a reservation for 6 and our table was ready when we arrived. I regret that I don't recall our servers name because she was fantastic. Along with our large party she had multiple other tables and still provided fantastic service. The food was phenomenal. Had the pork chop po boy and 10/10 highly recommend. First time here, definitely wiĺl be back

Overall Score

40 / 100

  • Health inspection grade 20/40
    Grade C
  • Dietary transparency 0/20
    None listed
  • Community rating 18/20
    4.6★ average
  • Hidden-gem status 0/10
    Not flagged
  • Track record 2/10
    Declining, 0% clean

Composite score from health grade, dietary options, ratings, and inspection record — distinct from the state-derived health grade.

Opening hours

Monday
11 AM to 9 PM
Tuesday
11 AM to 9 PM
Wednesday
11 AM to 9 PM
Thursday
11 AM to 9 PM
Friday
11 AM to 10 PM
Saturday
10 AM to 10 PM
Sunday
10 AM to 9 PM

Inspection history

The following records are from Florida DBPR public inspection records, most recent first.

  1. April 17, 2026 · Routine - Food

    Inspection Completed - No Further Action

    2 high-priority · 2 intermediate · 7 basic

    • 03 — Temperature control of foods (cold/hot holding, cooking, cooling, reheating)
    • 06 — Potentially hazardous foods properly thawed
    • 08 — Cross-contamination: raw foods separated; food protected during prep/storage
    • 10 — In-use food dispensing utensils properly stored (×3)
    • 14 — Food-contact & nonfood-contact surfaces properly designed/maintained
    • 16 — Dishwashing facilities; sanitizer test kits; gauges
    • 22 — Food-contact surfaces clean and sanitized
    • 23 — Nonfood-contact surfaces clean
    • 50 — Current license, properly displayed
  2. October 7, 2025 · Routine - Food

    Inspection Completed - No Further Action

    1 high-priority · 0 intermediate · 1 basic

    • 02 — Consumer advisory, date-marking & labeling of ready-to-eat foods
    • 03 — Temperature control of foods (cold/hot holding, cooking, cooling, reheating)

Safer options nearby

Higher-graded restaurants close to TIBBY'S NEW ORLEANS KITCHEN, by Florida DBPR grade:

This grade is calculated by us from Florida DBPR public inspection records — Florida does not issue official grades. How we calculate it →

Data last updated: April 17, 2026